Guide to Pizza in Fayetteville, Arkansas

By NWA Daily | Published November 10

Welcome to Fayetteville, home to some of the best pizza joints in Arkansas! Whether you're in the mood for deep dish, thin crust, wood-fired, or stuffed, we've got you covered. From the cozy, authentic Italian vibes at Geraldi's to the trendy, specialty pizzas and cocktails at Wood Stone Craft Pizza, there's something for every pizza lover in Fayetteville. Don't forget to check out Damgoode Pies for their delicious "stuffy" pepperoni pies with pink sauce, or Mojo's Pints & Pies for their hearty pizzas and great sports-watching patio. And for those Chicago deep dish cravings, Marley's Pizzeria & Bar has you covered. So come on down and satisfy your pizza craving at one of these fantastic pizza places in Fayetteville, Arkansas.

Wood Stone Craft Pizza

๐Ÿ“ Fayetteville (Uptown) - 3619 Mall Ave

๐Ÿ“ Fayetteville (S Town) - 557 S School Ave

Photo courtesy of Woodstone Craft Pizza

Located in both North and South Fayetteville, featuring fun and trendy atmospheres. They offer speciality pizzas and cocktails. Our go to is the wedge salad, Bloomington pizza, and pomegranate margarita. Donโ€™t forget to try the bone sauces for dipping! The Uptown location has an amazing new patio addition for great outdoor dining.

Instagram, Facebook

Damgoode Pies

๐Ÿ“ 37 E Center Street

Photo courtesy of Damgoode Pies

Fun location right off the square with a casual environment. Their traditional and specialty pies are both great, and they offer draft beer. We highly recommend the pepperoni โ€œstuffyโ€ with pink sauce.

Instagram, Facebook

US Pizza Company

๐Ÿ“ 202 W Dickson Street

Photo courtesy of US Pizza

This is the ideal place for pizza after a football game. They have a great patio right on Dickson Street with homemade ranch that is to die for. The classic pizza is great, but you can also spice it up with a variety of cool flavor combinations.

Instagram, Facebook

Bocca Italian Eatery & Pizzeria

๐Ÿ“ 2036 N College Ave

Photo courtesy of Bocca Italian

This nicer location has homemade everything! Woodfire pizza and plenty of roasted garlic! They also offer other Italian options if you want some variety.. try any of the homemade pastas or the steak!

Instagram, Facebook

Z's Brick Oven Pizza

๐Ÿ“ 2730 N College Ave

Photo courtesy of Z's Brick Oven Pizza

Enjoy Brick Oven Pizza, delicious sandwiches, Grandmother's pasta dishes and tasty salads while dining in at Z's! The cozy fireplace is an excellent spot to enjoy beer or wine with your meal.

Instagram, Facebook

Marley's Pizzeria & Bar

๐Ÿ“ 609 W Dickson Street #103

Photo courtesy of Marley's Pizzeria & Bar

Deep dish pizza that makes you feel like you are in Chicago. Located just off of Dickson Street, it is in the heart of downtown but slightly tucked away. The apps and wings are good too!

Instagram, Facebook

Tiny Tim's Pizza

๐Ÿ“ 21 W Mountain Street

Photo courtesy of Tiny Tim's

Located on the Fayetteville square the thin crust pizza is amazing with great lunch portions. Donโ€™t forget a side of their homemade ranch!


Tim's Pizza East

๐Ÿ“ 1813 E Mission Blvd

Photo courtesy of NWA Daily

This family owned and operated pizza joint is a staple in East Fayetteville. They are known for their pizzas being packed with flavor with lots of cheese!

Wicked Wood Fire Pizza

๐Ÿ“ 1946 N Birch Ave

Photo courtesy of Wicked Wood Fire Pizza

This is one of the favorites in Fayetteville. Right outside of Fossil Cove, a fantastic brewery, this food truck has some of the best wood fired pizza in the area. Our favorite is the Honey Pig for the perfect balance of spicy and sweet.

*Closed on Mondays

Instagram, Facebook


๐Ÿ“ 20 S University Ave

Photo courtesy of Geraldi's

Cozy, authentic, Italian vibes. They offer thick crust pizza and calzones with plenty of other amazing options for non-pizza people.. try the lasagna or traditional spaghetti and meatballs!

Instagram, Facebook

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville

๐Ÿ“ 1460 E Augustine Ln

Photo courtesy of Mellow Mushroom

Located near uptown Fayetteville, they are perfect for large groups. Their thick crust pizza has a great mix of artisanal and original flavors. Half priced Pizza on Wednesdays!

Instagram, Facebook

Mojoโ€™s Pints & Pies

๐Ÿ“ 2630 East Citizens Dr.

Photo courtesy of Mojo's Pints and Pies

A newly opened location in East Fayetteville that offers a great patio and hearty pizzas! A great place to watch sports with a full bar and plenty of TVs - inside and out.

Instagram, Facebook


๐Ÿ“ 1267 Steamboat Dr

Photo courtesy of Gusano's

Specializing in Chicago style pizza, they have several locations scattered around NWA. They offer trivia nights on Wednesday and happy hour all day Thursday, plus additional specials offered most other days. Check out their monthly event calendar to see what fun activities are happening.

Instagram, Facebook

Tonyโ€™s New York Style Pizza

๐Ÿ“ 412 W Dickson St

Photo courtesy of Tony's New York Style Pizza

Located on Dickson Street and staying open late on weekends makes for the perfect late night treat. Want pizza but donโ€™t want a whole pizza? This is the place for you.


Loafin Joe's

๐Ÿ“ 201 W Mountain St

Photo courtesy of Loafin Joe's

Located right off of the square is this great lunch spot with amazing thin or thick crust pizza, plus hearty sandwiches if youโ€™re not feeling pizza. Donโ€™t forget to try their legendary homemade chips!

Instagram, Facebook

Thanks for joining us on this tasty tour of the best pizza joints in Fayetteville, Arkansas! Whether you're a fan of deep dish, thin crust, wood-fired, or stuffed, these pizzerias have something for every pizza lover. So next time you're craving a slice (or an entire pie) in Fayetteville, be sure to check out one of these fantastic pizzerias. From the cozy, authentic Italian vibes at Geraldi's to the trendy, specialty pizzas and cocktails at Wood Stone Craft Pizza, there's something for everyone in Fayetteville. So grab a slice (or a whole pie) and enjoy some of the best pizza in Arkansas!

Subscribe to receive our daily newsletter

Know all the happenings in NWA with a 5-minute read of our free email newsletter every weekday.